2.5 million renters in low-income households risk financial distress as lack of insurance prompts use of credit to replace household losses.
- 61% of UK renters in low-income households have no contents insurance1
- One in three (33%) have had a potentially insurable loss in the last five years, rising to nearly half (47%) amongst 18-34-year olds2
- Of these, a quarter (27%) with no contents insurance, equivalent to 250,000 people, relied on credit to replace or repair their belongings3
- Renters with low incomes are more likely than other groups to suffer damage or loss of household contents from burglary, fire or flood
- Seven in ten (73%) low-income renters say they would find it impossible to meet an unexpected bill of £500 without help from an external source
- Lack of contents insurance amongst low-income renters can adversely affect emotional wellbeing.
2.5 million UK renters with incomes under £17,000 a year may be at risk of spiralling financial difficulties through a lack of household contents insurance, warns an independent research report for Aviva.
With low income renters more likely than other groups to suffer damage to, or loss of, possessions by burglary, fire or flood4, the report’s findings highlight that a lack of insurance is contributing to poor financial resilience and leading to a worrying use of credit and payday loans to replace or repair items.
The report, authored by Matthew Oakley of WPI Economics for Aviva, finds that one in three (33%) low-income renters have experienced a potentially insurable loss over the last five years. Yet despite the availability of contents insurance for as little as £1.30 a week for social housing tenants5, there is a significant gap in the take up of contents insurance amongst low-income renters, with just 37% having cover in place.
When belongings owned by low-income renters with no insurance were lost or damaged, nearly one in three (27%) resorted to credit cards, payday loans or bank loans to replace or repair the goods. As a result, almost all (95%) of those who did found that their long-term finances were adversely affected to some extent.
The research findings also show that lack of household contents insurance amongst low-income renters can have a distressing impact on the emotional wellbeing of an already vulnerable section of our society. Of those who say they would need to rely on credit if they experienced losses of £500, two in five (38%) say that they would find replacing their possessions stressful.
The report calls on the Government, insurers and organisations in social and private rented housing to innovate and build on existing initiatives and to focus on the vital role that insurance can play in boosting financial resilience and reducing financial distress.
It also highlights the work that Aviva is undertaking with leading not-for-profit social lender Moneyline as part of Cohort 5 of the FCA Regulatory Sandbox. This is to pilot a home contents insurance product for low-income customers that can be arranged at the same time as taking out a loan to provide protection against financial shocks.
Adam Beckett, Product Director for Aviva UK General Insurance, said: “It is concerning to see just how exposed many low-income households are to the financial and emotional impacts of their belongings being lost or damaged. Replacing costly TVs, phones, laptops and jewellery, especially through use of credit, can exacerbate financial distress and, as the report shows, give rise to stress and feelings of embarrassment and insecurity."
At Aviva we are committed to finding ways to improve the financial resilience of low-income households. Alongside the affordable tenants contents cover that we provide through Aon and other brokers to those in social housing, we are currently working with Moneyline to pilot a home contents insurance product for low-income customers. We hope that this will prove the worth of insurance to this vulnerable sector of society that are traditionally under-insured and lacking in financial resilience.
Findings in the report include:
- Seven in ten (72%) low-income renters are worried about their financial situation. Half (51%) currently have no savings at all and one in six (16%) say they have missed the deadline for a scheduled debt repayment in the last month. Three in ten (28%) believe that their personal finances will worsen over the next six months.
- 73% low-income renters also say they would find it impossible to immediately pay an unexpected bill of £500 without resorting to help from an external source (such as friends, family, a payday loan or credit). 62% said they would find it impossible to meet a bill of £250 themselves.
- This low level of ability to meet unexpected bills is particularly concerning given that data from Aviva’s tenant’s contents cover insurance scheme shows that the average payment on a claim is £551. Average claims for some specific circumstances were much higher, for example; flood (£3,610); theft (£1,273); and fire (£2,018). Given the size of these pay-outs, the majority of low-income renters, would be highly unlikely to be able to meet the costs without insurance protection.
- One in three (33%) low-income renters, equivalent to 1.4 million people, have experienced a potentially insurable loss over the last five years. Younger people aged 18-34 are particularly like to have experienced a loss in the last five years that potentially could have been met by insurance cover (47%).
- Figures from the Association of British Insurers have also shown that low-income households face higher risks, with tenants in social housing twice as likely to be burgled as owner-occupiers, arson rates 30 times higher in low-income communities than higher-income, and low-income households eight times more likely to be in a tidal floodplain than more affluent households.
- Despite these greater risks and clear needs, there is a significant gap in the take up of contents insurance amongst low-income renters. Just 37% have a contents policy, leaving 2.5 million (61%) of low-income renters at risk financially if they suffered a loss or damage to their belongings.
- In the last five years, 27% of low-income renters without contents insurance resorted to credit cards, payday loans or a bank loan to repair or replace to their belongings, equivalent to around 250,000 people. More worryingly, nearly all (95%) of these said using credit negatively impacted their longer-term finances to some extent.
- Amongst low-income renters who said they would need to rely on credit if they experienced a loss of £500, two in five (38%) say they would find the process of replacing their possessions stressful, and close to a quarter would be upset(23%) or anxious (22%).
- More than half (54%) of low-income renters identified with at least one negative emotion around not having insurance. 51% identified feelings of vulnerability, 38% nervousness, 38% insecurity and 34% stress in relation to their living situation because of their lack of cover.
To download the report in full:
Methodology: ComRes interviewed 4,217 UK adults (1,679 UK renters) online between the 20 and 23 May 2019. Data were weighted to be demographically representative of UK adults. ComRes is a member of the British Polling Council and abides by its rules.
Methodology: ComRes interviewed 1,006 UK low-income renters, defined as those earning less than £17,000 per annum before tax and housing costs, online between the 18 April and 2 May 2019. ComRes is a member of the British Polling Council and abides by its rules.
All population-level estimates combine results from ComRes polling with estimates of the number of low-income (<£17,000 per annum) households drawn from WPI Economics analysis of the Family Resources Survey. Department for Work and Pensions. (2018). Households Below Average Income, 1994/95-2016/17. [data collection]. 11th Edition. UK Data Service. SN: 5828, http://doi.org/10.5255/UKDA-SN-5828-9
Aviva has been providing an affordable and accessible contents insurance scheme targeted at social housing tenants since 1993. We currently work with over 90 local councils and other landlords across the UK. Prices vary by location but average at just £1.30 a week for £10,000 of cover. Policies are sold through the landlord and tailored to the requirements of consumers who might otherwise be excluded from insurance products.
About WPI Economics
WPI Economics is a specialist economics and public policy consultancy. We provide a range of public, private and charitable clients with research, modelling and advice to influence and deliver better outcomes through improved public policy design and delivery. You can find out more about our work at www.wpieconomics.com .
Director Matthew Oakley is a respected economist and policy analyst, having spent well over a decade working in and around policy making in Westminster. Before founding WPI Economics Matthew held a number of roles including Chief Economist and Head of Financial Services Policy at the consumer champion Which?, and Head of Economics and Social Policy at the think tank Policy Exchange. Matthew also led the Independent Review of Jobseeker’s Allowance sanctions that reported to Parliament in 2014, and previously spent eight years as an economist at HM Treasury.
Notes to editors:
- For information on how Aviva is helping our people, customers and communities impacted by COVID-19 visit: www.aviva.com/covid-19-our-response/
- We exist to be with people when it really matters, throughout their lives. We have been taking care of people for more than 320 years, in line with our purpose of being ‘with you today, for a better tomorrow’. In 2020, we paid £30.6 billion in claims and benefits to our customers.
- Aviva is invested in our people, our customers, our communities and our planet. In 2021, we announced our plan to become a Net Zero carbon emissions company by 2040, the most demanding target of any major insurance company in the world. This plan means Net Zero carbon emissions from our investments by 2040; setting out a clear pathway to get there with a cut of 25% in the carbon intensity of our investments by 2025 and of 60% by 2030; and Net Zero carbon emissions from our own operations and supply chain by 2030. Aviva has been leading this agenda for decades: Aviva was the first international insurer to go operationally carbon neutral in 2006 and we are champions of renewable energy and energy storage at our offices, allowing us to achieve our 2030 carbon reduction target (70% reduction on 2010 levels) 10 years early. Find out more about our climate goals at www.aviva.com/climate-goals and our sustainability ambition at www.aviva.com/sustainability.
- Aviva is a Living Wage and Living Hours employer and provides market-leading benefits for our people, including flexible working, paid carers leave and equal parental leave. Find out more at www.aviva.com/social-purpose
- We are focused on the UK, Ireland and Canada where we have leading market positions and significant potential. We will invest for growth in these markets. We will also transform our performance and improve our efficiency. Our transformation will be underpinned by managing our balance sheet prudently, reducing debt and increasing our financial resilience. We also have strategic investments in Singapore, China and India.
- Total group assets under management at Aviva group as at 31 December 2020 are £535 billion and our Solvency II shareholder capital surplus is £12.5 billion as at 31 March 2021. Our shares are listed on the London Stock Exchange and we are a member of the FTSE 100 index.
- For more details on what we do, our business and how we help our customers, visit www.aviva.com/about-us
- The Aviva newsroom at www.aviva.com/newsroom includes links to our spokespeople images, podcasts, research reports and our news release archive. Sign up to get the latest news from Aviva by email.
- You can follow us on:
- For the latest corporate films from around our business, subscribe to our YouTube channel: www.youtube.com/user/aviva