Flawed humans are more trusted than perfect machines.
November 2017. Uber hits the headlines (again) for covering up a data breach that affected 57 million customers and drivers.
November 2017. Fitness tracking company, Strava, publish a global heatmap of users' activity. “The largest, richest, and most beautiful dataset of its kind,” they say. What they don’t realise is that soldiers’ running routes reveal locations of secret US army bases in places like Afghanistan and Syria.
December 2017. The BBC launches a new scheme to help young people tell the difference between real and fake news. This follows a study that revealed many are unable to make the distinction.
This is the world we live in. We fend off attacks on our privacy. We buy beautiful, five-star-rated things that turn out ugly. We follow many – communities, companies, the media – but we trust few.
The decline of trust
The 2018 Edelman Trust Barometer reveals ‘a world of seemingly stagnant distrust.’ Even if that’s true, people do trust. We have to. We trust doctors to keep us heathy. We trust teachers with our children. We trust mechanics to keep us on the road.
For the first time, the trust barometer reports that the media is the least trusted institution globally.
The demise of confidence is driven primarily by a significant drop in trust in platforms, notably search engines and social media. Sixty three percent of respondents say they do not know how to tell good journalism from rumour or falsehoods or if a piece of news was produced by a respected media organisation. This lack of faith has also led to an inability to identify the truth.
Have we really lost the ability to identify truth?
We have more choice today than ever before. A few short decades ago, there were three TV news channels in the UK. Now there are hundreds. Factor in the internet and that number multiplies exponentially. They’re not all saying the same thing - so who’s version of the truth do you trust?
As trust in the media and our peers declines, personal experience becomes ever more important. Positive consumer experiences reinforce our decision to trust this news site or that company.
Surprise, surprise – people don’t trust financial services
Media might be the least trusted institution but financial services has long been one of the least trusted sectors.
For insurance, perhaps that’s because opportunities to experience making a claim are mercifully few. It follows that opportunities to build trust are few, too. And if we do have a poor customer experience, opportunities to rebuild that trust are fewer still, unless lightning strikes twice.
Research shows that a majority of people don’t trust insurers to pay out. Yet Aviva’s UK claims report shows the reality for Aviva UK in 2017 is:
of claims were accepted
was paid in cash settlements and services
was paid out every day
was paid out every minute
Other insurers have shared similar claims data. So, if numbers and percentages aren’t enough to convince us to trust insurers – and clearly, they aren’t – what is?
Aviva’s own reputation research shows that in insurance, in addition to service, reducing the complexity of products and building human relationships rather than transactional ones drive trust.
We also found that when a sector is not trusted, innovation is looked upon negatively and for the benefit of the industry and not the customer. Whereas for trusted companies, innovation is viewed as beneficial for consumers.
Flawed human vs perfect machine
As innovation and automation increases, so does the debate around its trustworthiness.
Would you go to a robot doctor? Would you entrust your child’s education to a robo-teacher? Would you feel safe in a driverless car? Many wouldn’t.
Studies show trustworthiness isn’t as much about judgements as how they are made. Judgements, even perfect judgements, based on cold calculation of consequences aren’t enough. We want machines to suffer the same sense of moral duty humans do.
Research indicates, too, that uncalculating cooperation signals trustworthiness. Husbands, wives, friends: there are some people we would unquestioningly do anything for, without a thought for our own best interests.
But who ever heard of a morally literate machine that makes judgements without calculating the consequences? Essentially, a machine that makes mistakes.
It’s illogical, but there it is. When it comes to trust, humans are irreplaceable.
From media to insurance, whatever the reason, who we trust influences where we spend our money, and where we don’t. The unignorable challenge for companies seeking long-term growth is how to earn trust, and how to keep it.
More of our Perspectives
What’s the point of tackling fraud?
30 Jul 2020
The fight against fraud sometimes feels impossible, but we’ll never stop. Peter Hazlewood, Group Financial Crime Risk Director at Aviva shares why we'll continue to speak up and take a stand against fraud today and tomorrow.
The expansion of the dormant assets scheme
14 Jul 2020
.... a force for good at a time of crisis
Activism by default – is it here to stay?
19 Jun 2020
Over the last two decades, businesses and brands have been making it easy to ‘do the right thing’, and consumers have happily ridden the wave. But, is this trend of default activism set to last?
Being a working carer...
9 Jun 2020
Debbie Bullock is the Wellbeing lead at Aviva. Here she tells her story about being a carer and how she’s balanced her caring responsibilities with work over the years.
Returning to the front line
14 May 2020
Aviva Senior Clinical Consultant Adam Hayward reports on his return to help the NHS.
Living alone in lockdown
24 Apr 2020
Nicki Taunt, works in our Corporate Creative Hub team in York. Here she shares her top tips for solo isolation during the COVID-19 outbreak.
Masks and hand sanitiser for key workers
9 Apr 2020
Marco Corrado is a Senior Colleague Experience Manager for our colleagues in London and South West England. He recently worked as part of a team to get supplies to key workers in the UK. Here’s his story.
Our numbers stand firm against storms
5 Mar 2020
Insurance exists to protect people’s property and livelihoods from extreme weather and catastrophe.
Saving (and) the world
5 Mar 2020
Helping people save for retirement is a growth opportunity for today’s insurers – but only if we protect the future our customers will retire into.
Time to invest in Mid-Lifers
24 Feb 2020
Traditionally, workers over the age of 45 have been thought of as “on their way out”. But today, Mid-Lifers are a growing proportion of the workforce. Investment in this age group must increase, to ensure their well being and experience are maximised, not overlooked.
Not ready to deal with a baby on my own
24 Feb 2020
We have offered Equal Parental Leave to our people since 2017. Here Becky and Kelly tell their story and the impact it has had on their lives since baby Ruby arrived.
Take action to shape your retirement
19 Feb 2020
Alistair McQueen, Head of Savings and Retirement at Aviva, reflects on the success of auto-enrolment in the UK and how more of us can take action to shape our own retirement.
UK pensions: millions need help
19 Feb 2020
The most important things in life are not always easy. Take pensions. With the onus now firmly on individuals to work out how best to manage their pension pot, millions in the UK are being set up for a fall.
Closing the climate protection gap
12 Feb 2020
The Aviva CEO talks to Aviva Investors' client publication, AIQ, about how the insurance industry is working to assess and manage the catastrophic risks of climate change.
Can we afford to live to 100?
19 Sep 2019
Retiring at 60 is a relatively new concept. As populations age – and age better – people are looking for ways to stay in work and sustain their retirement income. We present five charts that sum up the changing landscape.
Why not Fairtrade finance?
22 Jul 2019
We like to buy Fairtrade coffee. Why not Fairtrade finance, asks Steve Waygood.